DamyanBITW vs. LeanyMcMeany vs. BrokenKR

Status
Not open for further replies.

BrokenBlack

Newbie
DamyanBITW: I didn't see any kind of sync in the Titantron, it also lacks general Color Correction, and the Watermarks are very present, making the overall look bad. The Pacing was way too slow, and the Clip Selection could have been way better. Personaly I didn't enjoy the video.

Lean: Really liked the beginning, and the flow. The Titantron had an alright sync on the kicks, and snares. I really liked the overall look, meaning CC, and alright Nameplate, also I really liked that you blured the WWE Watermarks out, and tried to work around them with the Lens Distortion. Personally I really liked it.

BrokenKR: I think the Saber in the beginning was like really low quality, but I liked the glass overlay you used after.
The Pacing was really good, but the sync often was a bit off.
I do not like the look of the Nameplate.
The Clip Selection was good, and overall I really enjoy the tron.

Hard Choice, but I will go with LeanyMcMeany
 

Pehrox

Contributor
DamyanBITW vs. LeanyMcMeany vs. BrokenKR

I rate DamyanBITW' video as follows:

Synching - 5/10
Pacing - 2/10
Clip Selection - 4/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 5/10
Overall Entertainment - 2/10

LeanyMcMeany
's video as follows:

Synching - 5/10
Pacing - 6.5/10
Clip Selection - 7/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 7/10
Overall Entertainment - 6/10


and BrokenKRs video as follows:

Synching - 4/10
Pacing - 6/10
Clip Selection - 6/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 7/10
Overall Entertainment - 6/10


My vote would therefore go to: LeanyMcMeany
 

Leelee

Administrator
Staff member
DamyanBITW
Syncing - 4/10
Pacing - 4/10
Clip Selection - 4.5/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 4/10
Overall Entertainment - 5/10
21.5/50

LeanyMcMeany
Syncing - 7/10
Pacing - 7/10
Clip Selection - 7/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 7/10
Overall Entertainment - 7/10
35/50

BrokenKR
Syncing - 7.5/10
Pacing - 8/10
Clip Selection - 8/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 7/10
Overall Entertainment - 8/10
38.5/50

Rated your presentation a bit lower because a lot of the clips were choppy for some reason. If you were able to solve that issue then I would've given you an eight.

My Vote: BrokenKR
 

Vr37

Newbie
DamyanBITW
Syncing - 4/10
Pacing - 5/10
Clip Selection - 5/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 4/10
Overall Entertainment - 4,5/10
23,5/50

LeanyMcMeany
Syncing - 7/10
Pacing - 6/10
Clip Selection - 7/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 7/10
Overall Entertainment - 7/10
34/50

BrokenKR
Syncing - 6/10
Pacing - 7/10
Clip Selection - 7/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 6/10
Overall Entertainment - 7/10
33/50

My votes goes to LeanyMcMeany.
 

sfg

Contributor
DamyanBITW
Syncing - 3/10
Pacing - 3/10
Clip selection - 4/10
Presentation/aesthetic - 4/10
Overall entertainment - 3/10

LeanyMcMeany
Syncing - 7/10
Pacing - 7/10
Clip Selection - 6/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 7/10
Overall entertainment - 7/10

This is kind of a nitpick by me but I would've used different clips that's why I rated clip selection a little lower but still very good video.

BrokenKR
Syncing - 7/10
Pacing - 7/10
Clip selection - 7/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 8/10
Overall entertainment - 7.5/10

My vote goes to BrokenKR.
 
DamyanBITW:
Synching - 4/10
Pacing - 5/10
Clip Selection - 5/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 4/10
Overall Entertainment - 4/10

LeanyMcMeany:
Synching - 6/10
Pacing - 7/10
Clip Selection - 6/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 6/10
Overall Entertainment - 6/10

BrokenKR:
Synching - 7/10
Pacing - 7/10
Clip Selection - 5/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 6/10
Overall Entertainment - 7/10

VOTE:
BrokenKR
 

-EX-

Contributor
I rate DamyanBITW' video as follows:

Synching - 5/10
Pacing - 1/10
Clip Selection - 3/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 4/10
Overall Entertainment - 3/10

LeanyMcMeany
's video as follows:

Synching - 5/10
Pacing - 6/10
Clip Selection - 8/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 8.5/10
Overall Entertainment - 7/10


and BrokenKRs video as follows:

Synching - 4/10
Pacing - 5.5/10
Clip Selection - 6/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 6/10
Overall Entertainment - 6/10


My vote would therefore go to: LeanyMcMeany

 
Damyan:
Syncing - 2/10
Pacing - 3/10
Clip Selection - 4/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 3/10
Overall Entertainment - 2/10

Lean:
Syncing - 5,5/10
Pacing - 6,5/10
Clip Selection - 7/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 7/10
Overall Entertainment - 6/10

BrokenKR:
Syncing - 5/10
Pacing - 6/10
Clip Selection - 7/10
Presentation/Aesthetic - 5/10
Overall Entertainment - 6/10

Vote goes to Lean
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top