Voting Thread | WrestleMania Recap Challenge

Leelee

Administrator
Staff member


Voting Rules (Voting Ends Friday, May 12th)

Rate each category from 1-5; One meaning the lowest, Five meaning the highest. After you finish rating us, count up the totals. The total can not exceed 25 obviously. The editor with the most points wins. Do not give your vote as the tally of points will determine the winner.
Match Recap - Clarity of each match, did we get the pivotal points of the match?
Match Transition - Smooth execution from one match to the next
Editing Technique - Keeping pace with the tempo of song
Highlight Rate - Variation of clip selection, good camera angles and action
Presentation - How did we make the show seem? Exciting? Or a lifeless show?

wm35np2.png

wm35np.png

wm353np.png
 

Midnight Jazz

OG Staff
Staff member
Pehrox
Match Recap - 2
Match Transition - 3
Editing Technique - 2
Highlight Rate - 2
Presentation - 3
Total - 13/25

Soulfrost X
Match Recap - 4
Match Transition - 4
Editing Technique - 4
Highlight Rate - 4
Presentation - 4
Total - 20/25

Argudenhls
Match Recap - 5
Match Transition - 4
Editing Technique - 4
Highlight Rate - 4
Presentation - 5
Total - 22/25

My main grip with Pehrox's video was it had too much jarring cuts and the selection of clips were kinda stagnant. The Velveteen Dream match was a prime example. The rhythm just wasn't there for the most part either. The latter 2 videos had better transitioning and more of a cinematic experience. Argudenhls had the overall win because of its nice consistent pace.
 

YOHAN

OG Staff
Staff member
Pehrox
Match Recap - 4
Match Transition - 4
Editing Technique - 3
Highlight Rate - 3
Presentation - 3.5
Total - 17.5/25​

The song choice was awesome. Thought it matched the vibe of the night perfectly. There are many moments where I think another look at at the clip choice would have given the video more weight. Like removing parts of a clip and letting the impact carry those few seconds. Also more voiceovers would have worked as well. I don't think the video needed the TV lines. Overall my personal preference of the match.

Soulfrost X
Match Recap - 4
Match Transition - 4
Editing Technique - 3
Highlight Rate - 3
Presentation - 3
Total - 17/25​

Overall this was great. Lacked a lot of energy and felt a bit clinical at moments. A slight complaint you left out Bianca Belair from the entrances. The Cole X Gargano recap was spectacular in terms of capturing the story of that match. Overall great stuff

Argudenhls
Match Recap - 5
Match Transition - 3.5
Editing Technique - 3.5
Highlight Rate - 4
Presentation - 3
Total -19/25​

Although the song wasn't the greatest, the recap of the show was stellar and was told in a manner that let you really live within the many moments of the night. I wouldn't have mixed the main music lower than the voiceovers throughout the show and would rather have just mixed it according to when you would need the voiceovers. Overall, really great.

Great stuff everyone.
 

Leelee

Administrator
Staff member
Pehrox
Total - 30.5 out of a possible 50 points

Soulfrost X
Total - 37 out of a possible 50 points

Argudenhls
Total - 41 out of a possible 50 points

Winner: @argudenhighlights . PM me your 3 highlight reel requests.
Task of May's Challenge will be up at 7:30 pm est.
 
Last edited:
Top